In 2023, Vinny Corrao was selling insulation materials and wanted to earn some extra money. He bought a flatbed trailer, put a wood-burning oven on it and started working the party circuit, according to Newsday's February 2026 story on his shop. A year later he sold the trailer and bought a fully outfitted truck. He was soon catering up to five parties a weekend, and with a full-time job on top of that, he told Newsday, "It was decision time. I had to sell or grow." He chose to grow. On February 9, 2026, Americano Pizza Shop opened at 43 Berry Hill Road, just over the Syosset line from Woodbury.
Nine months later, Newsday's Best pizza on Long Island 2026, updated November 12, put Americano on its list. The list also includes Anna Pizza + Wine at 141 Woodbury Road. The two places run different kinds of rooms, but they share two things. Each one moved into a storefront that already had pizza history, and each one built its reputation on a sourdough starter.
141 Woodbury Road has been a pizza address for years
Before Anna, the storefront at 141 Woodbury Road was Pizzabar 141. LongIsland.com covered that opening in January 2020 and described the place as only a couple of months old. Its owners had replaced the former Frank's Gourmet and renovated the space completely, adding a pop-art mural across the whole store. It sold the standard Long Island slices along with salads, heroes and catering trays. One Yelp reviewer quoted in that LongIsland.com piece described a Buffalo chicken slice heaped with chicken and a chicken parm hero big enough for two.
In October 2024, Danny and Angela Aggelatos took over that same space and opened Anna, named for their daughter. Newsday's opening story reported that they did the room on a shoestring, with furniture from Home Depot and thrift shops. They picked their oven, a dual-fuel Fiero Forni, partly because it was the most affordable one that could go in without a forklift or taking out the front window.
Danny's training explains the pizza. His first job was at his uncle's slice shop in Bergen County, New Jersey. After that he worked with his brother Peter at Milkflower, a wood-fired pizzeria in Astoria, where he told Newsday, "I really started getting into pizza as a bread." He then cooked at Rolf & Daughters in Nashville and later at Bread & Salt, the Jersey City pizzeria-bakery. The couple came back to the area to be near family, and Angela's family lives in Dix Hills.
Anna is a sit-down, wine-forward pizzeria, a different kind of place from a slice counter. Newsday also put it on its 2026 Top 50 restaurants list, updated October 28, 2026, so it ranks among the best restaurants on Long Island, not only among the pizzerias.
43 Berry Hill Road had two pizza concepts before Americano
Americano's storefront has a similar history. Newsday reported that the small shop previously housed two concepts from Luca Pizzuti. The first was Aqua e Farina, a wood-fired pizzeria that opened in 2018. The second was Pinsa, which served the Roman flatbread of that name, opened in 2024 and, by the time of Newsday's February 2026 story, had closed the year before.
Corrao changed the format when he moved in. From the truck he had sold 12-inch Naples-style pies with puffy rims, baked in a wood-burning oven. At Berry Hill Road he switched to classic 18-inch New York pies, sold whole or by the slice, which meant new ovens and new technique. In the 2026 roundup, Newsday counted Americano as one of three well-known pizza trucks that found permanent homes this year. The other two are Josie's Pizza Bar in Glen Cove and Zozo's on the Bay in Bayville.
Long Island Press reported in March that customers were coming from across Long Island, and even from Queens and Brooklyn, to try the pizza.
Two sourdough starters, two different pies
Corrao told Newsday why he kept sourdough after leaving the truck: "If I didn't do sourdough, I'd be like every other pizza shop." That same story named Anna as one of the "artisanal" Long Island pizzerias where sourdough usually turns up. That puts both of the area's 2026 honorees on the same ingredient, a pre-fermented starter that adds flavor and texture and helps the crust rise.
The doughs come out differently.
At Anna, Aggelatos uses American flour instead of the Italian flour now in fashion. His blend is high-gluten, whole wheat and spelt, and his starter is based on rye. He bakes a little cooler than is traditional for Neapolitan pizza. Newsday describes the crust as tender but sturdy and never floppy. He pulls his own mozzarella and pickles his own long-hot peppers. The two pies Newsday describes in detail are a clam pie made with a reduction of clam juice and cream, and a mushroom pie with roasted shiitake and maitake over whipped garlic-confit cream, finished with barely caramelized onions.
At Americano, Newsday traces the crust to high hydration and a long, cool fermentation. The crust is crisp and thin across the middle, and you taste the sourdough most in the blistered edge. The sauce is clean and tangy, and the toppings are kept light. The menu is short and leans sweet. The roundup lists these bestsellers:
- Bee Sting: sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, hot honey and ricotta
- Sweet Heat: hot cherry peppers with hot honey
- Fig & Pig: prosciutto and fig jam
- Vodka Burrata Sicilian
The 2026 roundup also has some advice for pizza eaters. Its author argues that at too many slice shops, heavy or careless toppings now pull attention away from the dough, and asks readers to remember that with pizza, less is more. In Woodbury terms, that means ordering a regular slice at Americano or a Margherita at Anna and tasting the crust before moving on to the hot-honey pies.
The coal oven that came first on Jericho Turnpike
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings at 8063 Jericho Turnpike is Woodbury's longest-running pizza in this group. Newsday reported on August 5, 2011, that the Woodbury restaurant would open that next Tuesday as the chain's second Long Island location, after Carle Place. NFL Hall of Famer Dan Marino, a partner in the company, was scheduled for an invitation-only event there the night before, and "Eggplant Marino" was on the opening menu.
Anthony's Woodbury page says every pizza bakes in a 900-degree coal oven, which gives the crust a light char. The page lists gluten-free crust options and catering trays of pizza, baked pasta, salads and wings. Those catering trays are meant for groups. Anna and Americano are made to order, a pie or a slice at a time.
The turnpike has more slice-shop pizza going east into Syosset. Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant at 265 Jericho Turnpike makes its sauces, dough and breads from scratch every day, according to its own site. Reviews posted on that site mention specialty slices such as fig and burrata, eggplant rollatini and an upside-down Sicilian. Our August post on Syosset's restaurant group expansion covers more of the dining along that stretch of the turnpike.
Ordering for a full table
The three styles add up differently for a group, and the published prices show it. When Americano opened in February 2026, Newsday listed whole pies at $25 to $33 and slices at $4 to $5.50. Each 18-inch pie is built to be shared. At Anna's opening in November 2024, individual pizzas cost $17 to $24, closer to one pie per person at a sit-down dinner. Anthony's sells pizza by the tray for gatherings, through pickup or local delivery.
So with a full house and a mixed crowd over the holidays, there are three options. Americano is a stack of 18-inch pies and a counter where everyone picks a slice. Anna is a sit-down evening built around a wine list and a clam pie. Anthony's is the coal-oven tray you can pick up on the turnpike. The two newest options both work from sourdough, and both are in storefronts where someone was already baking pizza before 2026. If you then want to walk it off, our Woodbury trail post covers the paths that start near the same stretch of Jericho Turnpike.
Batul has worked from Woodbury for more than three decades. Knowing who bakes what on Woodbury Road and Jericho Turnpike is one part of local knowledge. The other part is what a home within a short drive of these blocks is worth right now. If you're curious about your own home's value, Batul Morbi will prepare a careful, Woodbury-specific valuation. Request a Home Valuation and we'll walk you through it.